Friday, December 15, 2006

Identity

So, first night of the play last night. I think it went well, we heard some positive stuff, which was nice. Very difficult to know when you don't spend that much time actually onstage, but the bits I was on for seemed alright.

Finally, to return to my much delayed blog from Wednesday, I am sick of being mistaken, misspelt, mispronounced and misunderstood. I understand, on the phone why someone may get my name wrong as I speak quickly and the sibilance of the end part of my name does run into the word "speaking" so that it often disappears. I do not understand email and letter confusion. It is written down. How, in any way, can people be so dense that they just don't double-check something before they reply? Somehow, they just seem to assume that I've got it wrong.

Similarly, I have a problem with being mistaken for somebody else. This happens a lot as Big Sis and I are similar-looking and for some people this constitutes us being the same person. Every time this happens I go and rant at Big Sis because I don't understand! We have similar faces, similar mannerisms and similar body shapes but there are enough differences to stop us from being the same. I choose to be ginger, she chooses to be blond. I'm three inches taller. I have a much longer face and goofy teeth. She has a smile like a normal person. Part of the problem is that Big Sis has a public role in her job and a number of people around where she works know her. They then see me, not knowing she has a sister, think I'm her, smile and say hello in a friendly way. As I don't know them, I'm not quick enough to twig and will give them a variety of responses a) confused smile, b) confused frown, c) blank face and, on a bad day, d) glare. I worry about this. It concerns me that I reflect badly on my pleasant and personable sister and makes me feel not so much a person in my own right but merely the bad side of her personality.

Of course, it's worse when the person in question does know both of us and still gets us mixed up. Surface differences are all well and good and I do get mistaken for any number of tall red-headed girls my age with glasses, not just for Big Sis. This just confirms my suspicion that people are basically stupid. But after talking to us both a certain amount and seeing us fairly often, I do get insulted when we're mistaken. Our personalities are markedly different and this, in itself, should overcome any superficial similarities of appearance.

I think where my real problem in being referred to by the wrong name or as the wrong person is that it makes me feel diminished. Every time, I feel like my uniqueness and my identity are being eroded. I moved churches aged about 14 because I found somewhere where I wasn't referred to constantly as someone's granddaughter, daughter or sister and wanted to be known in my own right. The main problem being that Granny was in the Guild, Dad was a steward, Mum ran Sunday School and Big Sis did the creche. There was no niche for me so no-one, except my friend FernBoy, knew who I was unless it was in relation to my relations. I didn't really start socialising at the Bench until I got cast in a few things because I didn't want the same thing to happen.

I don't know why I need to have such a fervent ownership of those things that make up who I believe my self to be like my name and appearance. It probably says something about my self perception that I have to have some grip on these relatively unimportant things to know who I am. This extends, unfortunately, to other elements of my life. Once I have got really close to people, I find it difficult when they are close to other people. I need people to tell me that they like me, especially MuleBoy. I remember getting freaked out when I was younger because I realised that other people could sing better than me because this meant that I did not own that talent. It is a constant effort not to touch things and people and aspects of my personality and scream "mine". It is an effort not to show how upset I can get by things that other people don't even notice. My Dad wrote a thank you letter to a family member for a birthday gift and told them what had happened on his birthday. He wrote that Mum cooked the meal, Big Sis baked a cake and Kitten poured the wine. For a start, the wine thing is a very minimal contribution and what was worse, I didn't even pour the wine. I was an afterthought and a slightly grasping conclusion to make a neat sentence. I can still remember how gutted I felt that I was so marginal. I reminded Dad that I had, in fact, written him a poem that had taken me a good deal of head scratching to get right so he wrote an addendum to the sentence that went "and wrote a poem". Now I felt marginalised, my achievement negligible and I had corrupted a nicely paced sentence with my melodramatic response. One of the most striking things about it is that I remember it so clearly now.

What I would like to know is what this says about me, other than deranged. Is this a sign of being spoilt, as my Granny told me and my parents repeatedly as I was growing up? Or is it a sign that I didn't have anything I considered truly mine growing up because everything I did, Big Sis did first or did with me? This would explain my scary need to have friends that are mine because this was one of the many things that we had to be fair about. We still have a number of mutual friends and it is still something that I struggle with. I don't go so far as when I was a teenager and questioned friends about who they liked best and why when Big Sis wasn't there, feeling cheated when they didn't immediately and fervently say that it was me.

Basically, I don't understand how identical twins cope. I love Big Sis to bits and don't resent her for this. I just have to suppress a lot of instincts when dealing with situations and spend a lot of my time angling for praise and reassurances of my place in the world and my position with other people. A lot of this blog is almost making excuses for myself and explaining certain personality quirks. I guess that's not what I intended. I don't want to make excuses for myself but I want to make myself clear. This is me. It's not pretty, it's not rational and I probably am crazy in a lot of ways. I do know that other people have crazy personality quirks and flaws like me and I don't consider myself to be special in this way. But I do like to articulate these quirks because it helps me not over-obsess about things. I've been obsessing about something that happened last week and trying to work out why I felt emotionally bruised by something extremely insignificant. So this is the outpouring of a week of obsession. Sorry.

3 comments:

Cracked Actor said...

Wow! What a great post. I like it when people just splurge their fears and foibles in such a private yet public forum.

In ways its difficult for me to understand how you feel, being predominanlty an only child, but many things still ring true. Without wanting to get too philosophical, I believe that everyone has several identities, one defined by the self and those defined by others, and life is a struggle to reconcile the two. But one doesn't negate the other. Perhaps they should be taken together as a whole if one wanted to define a comprehensive identity.

What bites, though, is when you feel that the way others perceive you is so different to how you see yourself, and in particular when you are identified by association with others.

We all respond to it in different ways, and we all have egos, as all that means is "I am" doesn't it? I always feel guilty about being so concerned about how I'm perceived by other people, even though I do make it difficult perhaps for people to get to know me. Plus I find it difficult to believe that people are being honest about me, whether criticising or praising.

If it makes you feel any better, I don't see how anyone could mistake you for anyone else (he stops to think whether he has been guilty of this in the past). You come across to me as unique, with a very strong personality (in the best way possible), and I can honestly say that I can't think of a single person who is like you. I also feel that I usually seem to know where I am with you, which can't be said for many.

Anonymous said...

Well, I don't think you're strange at all. And I don't think you need to justify your personality quirks either - although I completely understand why you do. I think it's human nature, we all try to justify ourselves in a vain attempt to make everyone else understand what we're thinking. If I ever manage to make anyone understand what I'm thinking it will be worthy of a front page spread in the national press.

Anyway, what I'm trying to say is that really, you are completely lovely and justifying yourself is entirely unnecessary. And Big Sis is completely lovely too, and the fact that you are different is what makes you two such individual and yet lovely people. Sibling "interchange" is entirely natural and at least you didn't end up biting a hole in your sister's hand and threatening to call the police as she was spreading foot and mouth disease around the village ... (I was only about ... well, okay, I was about 15 ...!!)

Similarly, being protective of who you are and what you believe in is also completely natural - I loathe the idea of anyone sharing any part of what I consider to be "mine" which is probably one of the reasons why I'm such an egotistical diva (as this post is proving!!). MuleBoy is yours and it's because of the fact you love him so much that you don't want to share him ... all I'm saying is that I think it's not only completely normal but also v romantic.

And I'm glad the play is going well. As you know, I have very critical reasons for not being able to come and see it, such as ... dammit, I have the attention span of a gnat and am far too self absorbed to watch anything more distracting than my own reflection in the mirror, but quite seriously I really hope it does go brilliantly and as ever I'm sure you are all fab.

I think I've said enough: but you are a v fabulous person, happy birthday for the weekend and when this play madness is over let me know a date and I will take you out for dinner to celebrate. Much love, Mrs DA xxxxxxx (currently sober-bird-seed-eating-yet-again-in-an-attempt-to-lose-weight-before-Christmas Accomplice) (and also Mr DA, currently in recovery from losing a major organ through the joy of modern medical science!)

Corrigan47 said...

My God but being a parent is a guilt provoking thing. So many sins of omission and commission by mistake! All the things one intended and all the things one never intended combine to produce a tapestry of life that one hardly recognises as one's own.
The even stranger thing is reading your child's blog about her personality and inner doubts and her acquisitiveness towards friends and relationships and knowing that she is revealing not only herself but you.
We do indeed all want to be unique but this isn't found in single strands of character trait or talent but in the weft and warp of the combined inherited genes we are handed down from those who went before.
I am very proud of a daughter who can articulate such thoughts and feelings to such a depth and to such an extent.
I was taught, by my grandmother, that some people live in a world that is black and white, but real people, grown up people, people with their heads screwed on right, live in a world where nothing is black and white, all is grey with many shades and tones. Picking your way through this world is fraught with difficulties and doubts and mistakes is what makes us alive and our choices are what makes us different from others.